The Fourth Floor WAS (Dumbledore in CoS was Re: The Keeper of the Keys.
M.Clifford
Aisbelmon at hotmail.com
Tue Sep 21 18:13:51 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 113530
> > Valky:
> > At the very least he created a secret entrance
> > to Hogwarts of his own via the fourth floor secret passage to
> > Hogsmeade.
> >
>
> Geoff:
> Can you enlarge on your source material for suggesting that?
>
Valky:
Why, certainly Geoff.
In POA when Harry is introduced to the Marauders map by Fred and
George they inform him that the secret passage on the Fourth Floor
that leads to Hogsmeade suddenly and by no reason apparent to them
became caved in and blocked during the winter of the previous year.
The Winter of the previous year was of course Christmas of the year
COS a time when "Harry, Hermione and the Weasleys had the run of
Gryffindor Tower....." because noone else stayed.
Between Gryff Tower and the Fourth floor are the Sixth which we know
nothing about and quite possibly is passed over by the staircases
because no canon ever places Harry there in five years, and the
Fifth which is the prefects bathroom floor that Harry discovers, to
his surprise, exists after he is told about it.
Suffice to say, it appears somewhat that the Gryffindor common room
might lead out to a staircase usually facilitating the lower
grade/Non prefect students direct access from the GT entrance to the
Fourth Floor and bypassing the two between floors.
So to say that if Tom!Ginny was having the run of Gryff Tower with
her unsuspecting brothers in the winter of COS, the opportunity for
Tom to become easily acquainted with the relative immediate
surrounds of Gryff Tower is likely to have been _in the Winter of
COS_.
So it flows like this:
Before Christmas, Ginny gets private tour of GT from F and G they
tell her, and so likeise Tom, about the secret passage, later
dismissing it from their minds.
After Christmas, while HRH are busy with their polyjuice potion and
the ensuing events, Tom!Ginny find themselves some bit more alone
than usual and Tom takes advantage of the quiet moment to slip down
to the mirror and use the knowledge he has gained. Or even during
the Christmas feast where I simply cannot find Ginny anywhere.
Either way the unexplained collapse of the fourth floor passage in
winter of COS and the lack of Tom!Ginny having anything satisfying
to do at that particular time leads well into suspicion dont you
agree? And this is my theory.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive