Hagrid/ was Snape and Neville OOPS forgot to change it

[garybec]

No: HPFGUIDX 113569

patientx3 at a...> wrote:

(personally, I cannot stand Hagrid, the fact that the 
author likes him makes no difference). 


Tonks:

Ah.. now what have you got against good ol' Hagrid? He is a 
sweetheart.. good natured .. not the sharpest.. but hearts in the 
right place.  What could anyone have against our buddy Hagrid? ??

Tonks_op

Becki here;

Don't get me wrong, I do like Hagrid, but there is one thing that 
bothers
me.  In PS/SS,  the dreaded dragon egg incident.  First he was so 
thick 
to even except it and then, hatch it, and then let Harry and 
Hermione take
the fall for trying to get rid of it,  when they were just trying to 
save his butt! 
They lost 150 house points for that one and the humiliation from the 
rest of 
the school, and they had to do detention, which Hagrid implemented!  
What 
is wrong with this picture?!  To let some 11 year olds take the fall 
for
your own stupidity!  That is just wrong.  And I don't ever remember 
him 
apologizing for getting them in trouble.  I feel that was very low, 
and he should
have gone to Dumbledore and confessed.  

Becki (who just finished listening to her new copy of PS audio.  
Funny
how a different actor brings a different perspective).