Avada Kedavra and Godric's Hollow
eloise_herisson
eloiseherisson at aol.com
Wed Sep 22 08:37:27 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 113582
Khilari:
>But what occured to me recently was, why did [Voldemort's] body
> disintegrate? Avada Kedavra kills without leaving a mark, we know
> that from canon. On the other hand inanimaate objects can be
blasted
> by it and disintegrate (I think, does this happen to the gravestone
> in GoF?)and a killing curse sets fire to the concierge's desk in
OotP.
> So, in order for LV's body to be destroyed, it should have been
> inanimate. Is this possible? His steps towards immmortality could
> have ended in making his body into an object which his spirit
> controlled rather than a proper part of him. So the AK only hit his
> body, destroying it, but not the resident spirit.
Do we know that his body was destroyed? Voldemort says that he
was "ripped from" his body. If there was no body I wonder how exactly
the WW knew that Voldemort was "dead" with no witnesses to the event,
or at least ones likely to advertise it (as far as we know) surviving.
As you say, I think the rebounding AK *did* kill Voldemort's body,
but that the transformations he had undergone stopped *him* from
dying, leaving him still with an earthly but non-corporeal existence.
But I don't think that we know that his body was destroyed as such.
I don't think it's an AK that damages the gravestone in GoF. The
marble angel that Harry dives behind is damaged by spells which
manifest as jets of *red* light, whereas AK is characterised by green
light. We don't know what the killing curse was that set fire to the
security guard's desk, although it's a fair guess it was an AK as it
was as part of a volley of green jets of light directed at Dumbledore
by Voldemort.
It *is* inconsistent, though. If an AK can set fire to something,
then you would expect that even if the bodies of its victims were
unmarked, their clothing would show some sign of the curse.
We have to account for the effect of the failed curse on the house at
Godric's Hollow. My guess is that it was destroyed by the power
released when Voldemort's essence was ripped from his body (similar
to the power which is released in Pullmans HDM universe when human
and daemon are separated).
~Eloise
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive