Avada Kedavra and Godric's Hollow
khilari2000
hannah at readysolve.com
Wed Sep 22 13:09:20 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 113588
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "eloise_herisson"
<eloiseherisson at a...> wrote:
> Khilari:
>
> >But what occured to me recently was, why did [Voldemort's] body
> > disintegrate? Avada Kedavra kills without leaving a mark, we know
> > that from canon. On the other hand inanimaate objects can be
> blasted
> > by it and disintegrate (I think, does this happen to the
gravestone
> > in GoF?)and a killing curse sets fire to the concierge's desk in
> OotP.
> > So, in order for LV's body to be destroyed, it should have been
> > inanimate. Is this possible? His steps towards immmortality could
> > have ended in making his body into an object which his spirit
> > controlled rather than a proper part of him. So the AK only hit
his
> > body, destroying it, but not the resident spirit.
>
> Do we know that his body was destroyed? Voldemort says that he
> was "ripped from" his body. If there was no body I wonder how
exactly
> the WW knew that Voldemort was "dead" with no witnesses to the
event,
> or at least ones likely to advertise it (as far as we know)
surviving.
>
> As you say, I think the rebounding AK *did* kill Voldemort's body,
> but that the transformations he had undergone stopped *him* from
> dying, leaving him still with an earthly but non-corporeal
existence.
> But I don't think that we know that his body was destroyed as such.
>
> I don't think it's an AK that damages the gravestone in GoF. The
> marble angel that Harry dives behind is damaged by spells which
> manifest as jets of *red* light, whereas AK is characterised by
green
> light. We don't know what the killing curse was that set fire to
the
> security guard's desk, although it's a fair guess it was an AK as
it
> was as part of a volley of green jets of light directed at
Dumbledore
> by Voldemort.
>
> It *is* inconsistent, though. If an AK can set fire to something,
> then you would expect that even if the bodies of its victims were
> unmarked, their clothing would show some sign of the curse.
>
> We have to account for the effect of the failed curse on the house
at
> Godric's Hollow. My guess is that it was destroyed by the power
> released when Voldemort's essence was ripped from his body (similar
> to the power which is released in Pullmans HDM universe when human
> and daemon are separated).
>
> ~Eloise
It was definitely a killing curse that set fire to the desk, I
checked. "He sent another killing curse at Dumbledore, but missed,
instead hitting the security guard's desk, which burst into flame."
As to the body being destroyed, perhaps I was wrong about that, does
anyone remember LV saying anything else about this?
Khilari.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive