Dumbledore in CoS was Re: The Keeper of the Keys.

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Fri Sep 24 19:35:33 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 113759

> > SSSusan wished that someone would tackle her 
> question of whether  Parseltongue is required to make the SINK 
> open *or* the serpent DOOR  open *or* both....<
> 
Pippin responded:
> That one's easy. Harry tried English on the sink and nothing 
> happened. It's also quite possible that the tiny snake scratched 
> on the pipe is only visible in the presence of a Parselmouth. 
> <snip>

Carol asks:
I agree (based on the same evidence) that Parseltongue is required to
open the entrance in the girls' restroom. My problem is with
Possessed!Ginny opening the Chamber using Parseltongue (which she must
have done, via Tom speaking through her). Wouldn't Myrtle have heard
the strange hissing and looked out to see what was happening? How
could she have missed seeing the basilisk come out? It happened at
least four times before Ginny herself was (somehow) taken into the
Chamber. Why wouldn't Myrtle hear and see what was happening? or did
possessed!Ginny choose times when Myrtle was absent from the restroom?

Carol 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive