Marauder's Map, A History; Wasn't Wormtail Worried?

karen_lvssr klevasseur at earthlink.net
Sun Sep 26 12:55:24 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 113949

:, "Bex" <hubbarrk at r...> wrote:
> ><snip>
> > And as for why the twins never noticed a Peter Pettigrew? 
Well, 
> > there are several reasons:
 (snip)> 
> > 2) It's pretty clear that students (Gryffindors, at least) don't 
> > associate with other students outside their house and/or 
year. In 
> > the off chance that the twins noticed a Peter Pettigrew, they 
may 
> > have written it off as a student they don't know. (snip)> 
> > 3) <snip> Thus 
their 
> main 
> > concern would have been who was in the hall they were in, 
who was 
> > close enough to hear them, and perhaps which professors 
were 
> where. <snip>

 
> Romulus Lupin:
> I agree with your post. I have one point to make. I think the 
> Marauders never appear on the map by their full names, but 
only by 
> their nicknames <snip>


Karen L.
When Fred and George first had the map, don't you think they 
would have stayed in their dorm room studying it before they 
went looking for secret passageways?  They must have seen PP 
on the map, but blew it off as someone they didn't know, or just 
didn't care.  If they would have seen the name "wormtail" walking 
around the castle, that may have sent them looking for "wormtail" 
because they would want to know who  "wormtail"  was and 
congratulate him on making such an extraordinary map!  So I 
don't think that the Marauder's nicknames would have appeared 
on the map (sorry Lupin).






More information about the HPforGrownups archive