Hogwarts Homework -- Practicing Spells Away From School

distaiyi distaiyi at yahoo.com
Thu Sep 30 16:56:57 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 114292

Meri <meriaugust at y...> wrote:

> IIRC Hogwarts homework is mostly essays. We've never seen Harry 
> have a practical homework lesson (such as "practice wingardium 
> leviosa") though he did have History of Magic essays in PoA. So
> maybe that's how they get around that one. 


And yet it doesn't explain him getting away with Lumos charms under 
the covers (assuming that movies can be taken as canon). 

It would seem more reasonable to look at it from a location/intent 
aspect. Magic done away from home in the muggle world would be 
strictly forbidden... magic done with a particular intent would be 
strictly forbidden... seems that since magic is intent and formula 
that they could monitor for intent as well.

Distaiyi





More information about the HPforGrownups archive