The Seven Charms in HPSS

[Ravenclaw Bookworm]

No: HPFGUIDX 126953


Danielle wrote:
> Miss Nitpicky here, but the devil's snare didn't cure those who were 
> petrified in book two, that was the mandrakes. So task 2 the devil's 
snare really didn't have anything to do for the plot of book 2.


I was confused when I first read that, too.  If you re-read it, I 
think you'll see that "B.G." was showing a possible connection between 
the 7 tasks and the 7 books.  The 2nd task was the Devil's Snare, the 
2nd book had the Mandrakes (Herbology).

Hope that helps.
Ravenclaw Bookworm