Snape vs. Sirius (was: Snape's Stubbornness)
finwitch
finwitch at yahoo.com
Mon Apr 4 05:23:10 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 127040
>
> Alla:
--
> Did Sirius deliberately told him? Most likely, but unless Snape was
> under Imperio, he went there under his own free will. Do I applaud
> Sirius for what he did? Of course not, but there is a huge
> difference
> between saying something provocative and sending someone to meet
> their possible death.
Finwitch:
I quite agree. In fact, we don't even know exactly what Sirius told
Snape, or if he was even talking TO Snape for that matter. In fact,
the way things are, why would Snape and Sirius have even TALKED to
each other long enough for Snape to get that information? For all we
know, Sirius could have been talking with James about getting past the
WW without the rat (who might have been in sick-bay or something,
possibly due to Snape) and Snape just happened to overhear them. (And
thought later that they set him up with a staged conversation!)
And when Lupin said 'that trick', he's talking about Severus Snape
making others look bad. (the 'forgotten' goblet and who knows what he
did at school)
Finwitch
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive