Harry's Turban Dream
finwitch
finwitch at yahoo.com
Mon Apr 4 08:11:52 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 127053
Steve:
>
> Don't you find it odd that the author would give us, the reader,
> insight into such a strange dream, but not allow the character to
> remember it.
>
> I guess on one hand, that's not that uncommon, all of us frequently
> wake from dream, and the memory of those dreams quickly fade from out
> mind. So, it may have been nothing more than that.
>
> But still... it seems odd.
Finwitch:
It does indeed. Harry also begins to forget many of his scar-brought
dreams... And there's the caged dream at the beginning of CoS. Both
show what's going on, but the Turban-dream was obscure. What of the
Flying Motorcycle - a dream Harry DID remember? Was it a dream OR a
memory of his Flight to the 4 Privet Drive - as well as predicting
Hagrid's arrival later?
This dream-issue follows up with the Divination. Tea-leaves. (Harry's
prediction was correct; it came true when Ron got his 'Scabbers back')
- but particularly Trelawney's issued homework: Dream Diary.
We might also remember that most of Harry's visions - those of
Voldemort, with his scar hurting - have been TRUE.
It might be that Harry has Seer-abilities, that come as dreams to him.
His mistreatment over the Motorcycle Dream may have prompted him to
forget those without his scar hurting...
Hmm-- is this somehow linked to Neville forgetting things like
passwords, books and such?
I think Harry has Seer-abilities, and if he has a dream that's not a
clear vision he forgets it. He just doesn't realise it yet - (and with
Hermione's attitude on Divination, she's not helping) - but I think
that in later books, Luna may do so. Or Neville. (who's sleeping in
the same dorm). Or whoever gets Harry out of Privet Drive in HBP.
Finwitch
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive