Snape's Stubbornness

Ann Crutchley rosie_27018 at yahoo.com
Tue Apr 5 02:01:30 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 127106


> Jaanis:
> I wanted to add that Snape *is not* a "good guy", and if I'm 
> not mistaken, Rowling has stressed this in a few interviews. 
> Maybe you can put the phrase in quotes meaning that he is with 
> the OotP and against DEs and Voldemort, but he is not a *good* 
> guy.


Snape is on the good side, not necessarily a good person even 
Dumbledore has referred to that as an old man's mistake, that he 
let Snape teach Harry to control his thoughts when Snape couldn't 
get over what James and Sirius did to him in school. But being on 
the good side for how long?  The mark burns his skin. Snape is cruel and out for revenge against Harry for what James & Sirius did. 
Someone should be questioning Snape and his motives; until we know 
why Dumbledore trusts Snape he could still be the enemy.

Ann








More information about the HPforGrownups archive