Mixing the Magical and Muggle Worlds
Megan
WNCMegs at aol.com
Wed Apr 6 02:49:04 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 127165
Richard <jones.r.h.j at w...> wrote:
> I'm confused by the apparent lack of knowledge of the Muggle
> world by witches and wizards.
>
> In the first book, it says that "loads of" students come from
> the Muggle families. So any witch or wizard who went to
> Hogwarts should know stuff about them. Like how to dress like
> a Muggle. <snip>
>
> The magical world has at least one train and one bus, a flying
> motorcycle, a flying car, the Ministry has other cars, and yet
> Arthur head of the Muggle department keeps making elementary
> mistakes about technology.
>
> Shaklebolt miscalls "firearms" "firelegs" and yet Hagrid knew
> what the Dursleys' shotgun was. <snip>
Megan:
I have had the same thoughts. Arther WORKS in the Misuse of Muggle
Artifacts Office and should therefore know SOMETHING about Muggle
life. They all dress in Muggle clothes from time to time and how do
they do get the items? Maybe there is a Wizard who has a shop
selling Muggle Clothes. This could explain why some Wizards own
Muggle Clothing and do not realize it is the RIGHT Muggle clothes
(remember the insident at the Quidditch World Cup?)
Some Wizards may choose to NEVER learn about Muggles. I too find it
amazing that most Wizards are clueless about it. I think Shackbolt
knew the correct term, however, and used the wrong term to stall
time to talk to Arthur. Muggles seem to be seen as "below" Wizards
and this may be another reason why Wizards do not understand or care
to understand and learn about them.
Just a thought!
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive