JKR's site up-date - Rumours Section
Jen Reese
stevejjen at earthlink.net
Thu Apr 7 16:45:40 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 127269
> vmonte responds:
>
> I'm really worried about her comment that there are people who
will
> be upset with the ending but that she really wrote the books for
> herself and had to be true to herself.
>
> What could make people so upset? The only thing I can come up
with
> is that she is planning on killing Harry. That would be very
> upsetting indeed. What do you all think?
Jen: Well, if HBP makes it clear that the series is more straight-
forward and not detective fiction or a conspiracy plot, a segment of
fandom would probably be seriously disappointed.
By the end of HBP we should have a pretty clear idea where she's
headed. 85% of the series will be out there, and more and more
theories will drop like flies with each update from the website.
OTOH, if she's not going for a more face-value approach, another
segment of fandom could be disappointed. If it's clear ESE!Lupin is
true or some conspiracy DD plotted at Godric's Hollow or the like,
that could be a sticking point for some readers. Myself included :).
Not that I'd ditch the series, but I'll have to do some major mental
gymnastics to come to terms with that.
But as someone said on this thread, I do think JKR meant that some
people will be disappointed by HBP, not the series as a whole.
Jen
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive