How will Harry kill LV - Dementors through the Veil

Steve bboyminn at yahoo.com
Fri Apr 8 23:32:48 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 127329


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "elady25" <imamommy at s...> wrote:
> imamommy:
> 
> I'm still staking my claim on my overly elaborate, highly unlikely, 
> but fun to think about anyway theory:  Somehow, the Dementors take 
> care of VM.  To elaborate, I think somehow Harry will somehow have
> VM inside him at the time, through posession or otherwise, and the 
> Dementors will kiss Harry but only suck out VM's soul.  
> 
> My rationale, which is, admittedly thin, is this:  the Dementors, and 
> paricularly their kissing ability, is what scares Harry the most.  
> Also, this quote from the World Book Day chat:
> 
> ,,,edited,,,
> 
> So maybe this sounds crazy, ... it's my story and I'm 
> sticking to it.  And if I'm right, my DH owes me a nice dinner out.
> 
> imamommy

bboyminn:

I don't know if I buy your theory, but it's no more far-fetched than
my Harry and Voldie go through the Veil theory. It's is possible that
the reason the Dementor are so strongly drawn to Harry, is that they
sense Voldemort in him. 

One could speculate that somehow Voldemort has some control over the
Dementors. When I say 'control' I'm thinking more along the lines of
something like blackmail, or some coercive power. 

Certainly, he can offer the Dementors a wider range of 'Food' than the
Ministry will allow, and I'm sure the Dementors like that, but I'm
looking for some excuse for the Dementors to resent Voldemort, to have
a grudge against him. Or perhaps, it's simply something in Voldemort's
tormented past that make him ideal Dementor food.

So, the point is, that it's really Voldemort that the Dementors
desire, and that's why they are drawn to Harry, because they sense a
piece of Voldemort in him. 

So, I don't see it any harder to fantasize a means by which they are
maneuvered into a position where Voldemort has possessed Harry, or
here's a twist, HARRY has possessed Voldemort, than for me to
maneuvere the gang into a situation when H&V go through the Veil
together. In your scenario, the Dementors, in that moment in which H&V
are conjoined, sense a vulnerability in Voldemort and attack, Suck out
Voldie's soul and either leave Harry's behind or someone intervenes to
prevent the Dementors from getting Harry too. 

By the way, in one of my many 'Through the Veil' scenarios, Harry does
have the power to Possess. Further, the one who is the possessor, has
power to control the possessee. I Harry is the Possessor, he can
control Voldemort...cool.  So, Harry possessing Voldemort drags him
into the Veil, or in your case, entices the Dementors to come and get
him.  

I feel very deeply, that Harry's power to Possess is actually going to
appear in the story

It's just a thought.

Steve/bboyminn








More information about the HPforGrownups archive