How will Harry kill LV
Karen Barker
karenabarker at yahoo.co.uk
Sat Apr 9 03:46:20 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 127338
Jim Ferer wrote:
<snip>
> Then ask this: Of the two, Harry and Voldemort, who are linked,
what
> would happen to the other if one of them lost his magic? What would
> happen to Voldemort if magic left him?
<snip>
> If Harry destroys his own ability to do magic,
<snip>
After this kind of death, Harry will be "reborn" into the love and
adulation of his friends and the wizarding world. His ability to
love - love enough to make the sacrifice - remains, because it's the
power Voldemort knows not.
>
> This hypothesis is attractive to me because it's the most
> heartwrenching sacrifice Harry could ever make,
<snip>
And Harry, Frodo-like, saves the world for everyone
> but himself.
<snip>
That's a really good answer and it's got me thinking alright. If
Harry did sacrifice his magic, he'd have to go back to living as a
muggle and would lose day-to-day contact with the WW, and Ron,
Hermione etc (if still alive, which in this instance would be more
moving if they were) would carry on being witches/wizards without
him. Perhaps it would be kinder for someone to perform a memory
altering charm so that Harry forgot all about everything. We would
then come full circle. Harry would be famous in the WW, his name
known to every man, woman and child and there probably really would
be a 'Harry Potter Day' and Harry would once again be completely
oblivious to the whole thing.
I hope not though!
On a slight tangent it was mentioned that magic was 'bestowed' on
Harry by LV's AK on him as a baby. What about the possibility that
he was actually born a squib and *all* his magical ability came from
LV? Therefore once the connection between them was broken he was
left as a squib again etc etc
Karen
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive