Neville is The One

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 127527



> 
> But Voldemort and Dumbledore missed one fact. In Godric's Hollow an 
> Avada Kedavra went from the baby Harry onto Voldemort. What 
> happened? It failed. Why? Harry is not The One. If he was, Voldemort 
> would be dead. Hence Neville is The One.
> 
> Cheers,
> 
> Dumbledad.
> 
> PS I'm sure this has been done to death already; please point me to 
> your favourite rebuttal or proposal post if it has.

Doddiemoe here:

Of course this has been done to death...

Neville is far more marked as an "equal" than Harry ever was...scar or 
not..

Tom Riddle DID have a parent living while he was at hogwarts.. as does 
neville...

but to have a Surviving parent that you have no chance of relating 
to...well...see what I mean?!???

If I'm wrong...we'll learn more about the "marking" in book six...

Unless Peter Pettigrew repaid his life debt to harry already by 
allowing his godfather to survive...(which I do not think is true at 
ALL).  It would be ever so fitting to have the heir to have a 
completely VISIBLE scar and the "spare" to have a "NOT-SO-VISIBLE" 
scar....

For all we know Neville's scar took on the persona of "Trevor the 
Toad".

Thing is...is we pursue the Neville is the one theory...it makes 
Neville coming into save the day..and it makes a great deal more 
conspiracies on every characters parts aside from Snape and maybe 
Hermione's....

There is only one thing I feel certain of in my mind..

THERE IS a reason why snape is horrible to BOTH Neville AND Harry..and 
JK has pretty much explained why Snape dislikes Harry..but she has 
never explained why Snape dislikes Neville so much!

DD