What would dissapoint you about HBP? -- Grawp

bbkkyy55 bbkkyy55 at yahoo.com
Sun Apr 17 17:53:41 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 127681


Lupinlore asked:

>>  7) Seeing a great deal of Grawp.  >>

Oh yes. I truly hated that whole section.  Even Hagrid with the 
giants was a strain for me.  What was the purpose of all that, 
except to have Grawp drip blood on the kids so the thestrals would come?  One would have to hope that they play some part in the 
future books that would be a whole lot easier to digest.  The idea 
of having to read about them again is not pleasant, but maybe there will be something more interesting happen.  I hope, I hope, I hope.

What was JKR's purpose in putting Grawp in the book?  I know JKR 
said he would be back and would be much better behaved.  Oh dear!

Bonnie (maybe I'm prejudiced against giants)











More information about the HPforGrownups archive