"A Little Romance" -- Ginny

[lunamk03]

No: HPFGUIDX 127931


> > Luna:
> > It was Ginny the one who really got to him and gave him hope.
> 
> GEO: 
> If I recall she cheered him up by giving him information that 
> turned out to be false and misleading so in the end listening 
> to Ginny really didn't turn out to be his benefit considering
> his possession by Voldemort was quite different than that she 
> experiences via his diary.


Luna :
Yes, Ginny was possessed by a memory, a dairy left behind by Tom M. 
who at that tender age was already calling himself LV and was 
creating pieces of Dark magic like the dairy and killing his father 
and his family
 Also, if you pay attention to how LV describes his 
possession of animals, and how they die after a while because the 
possession sucks the life out of them, you'll see how Ginny was 
indeed possessed and was having her life being sucked by Tom M./LV 
memory. I don't think Ginny's info was neither misleading nor false 
as she was right: based on her experience she got to the conclusion 
that Harry was not being possessed at that time. And that's what 
Harry needed to know at that specific moment. Anywhoo, this is 
another discussion


Back to my original point. I am not discussing the quality of the 
information Ginny gave to Harry, it is clear that she wasn't lying 
to him. I was giving an example of how Hermione was unable in that 
situation to cheer an unhappy, miserable Harry up. She is aware of 
this, she wants Harry to be happy, she knows she doesn't have all 
the tools to make him happy so she required Ron and Ginny's support in Grimmauld Place. I love Hermione, I know she loves Harry (as a 
friend, so far) and she wants him to be happy and save. I just want 
to put into perspective this so often mentioned scene in Grimmauld 
Place that some people like to bring up in order to make the point 
on Hermione being the « only one » who could help Harry. This argument backfires as we see that the one actually cheering him up and getting to his heart is Ginny, not Hermione