Killing Harry for Fun and Profit

amiabledorsai amiabledorsai at yahoo.com
Sun Apr 24 15:16:46 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 128006


bboy:
> 
> <<Though few of us do, we should ask ourselves if Lily's love 
> protection is Universal, or is it unique to Voldemort.>>
> 
Phyllis:
> I don't think this is clear.  In Ch. 37 of OotP, Dumbledore tells 
> Harry "While you can still call home the place where your mother's 
> blood dwells, there you cannot be touched or harmed by *Voldemort*"  
> (my emphasis).  This would suggest that the protection is unique to 
> Voldemort, but in PoA, no one seemed concerned about Harry's safety 
> after Sirius' escape from Azkaban until he ran away from Privet 
> Drive.  So presumably there was some thought that Harry was safe from 
> someone other than Voldemort (in this instance, Sirius) while at home 
> (where he is protected by a charm that uses the spilling of Lily's 
> blood to protect him). 


I've long had the idea that Harry's protection at Privet Drive extends
not just to Voldemort, but to Voldy's agents, as well.  Otherwise, the
protection isn't really worth much--"Say Lucius? Be a dear and pop
over to Little Whinging for me, please." 

That would be why, if it's true that no one was worried before Harry
left PD (we only see Harry's POV, and we *know* things where hidden
from him) they weren't worried about Sirius--they thought he was one
of Tommy's Toerags, and hence, unable to touch Harry in Petunia's home.

Amiable Dorsai












More information about the HPforGrownups archive