Prophecy wording

[Tonks]

No: HPFGUIDX 128023


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "B.G." <hambtty at t...> wrote:
> The Prophecy ends with "The one with the power to vanquish the Dark 
> Lord WILL BE BORN as the Seventh month dies (this is Harry).  
> 
> JKR stated in an interview that, "She and Trelawney worded the 
> Prophecy very carefully".  There are two - THE ONE BORN as the 
> seventh month dies and THE ONE WILL BE BORN when the seventh month 
> dies.


Tonks:

Now wouldn't it be a kicker if it were neither one of them. Yes, I know 
the series is about HP and he has the mark and LV is after him all the 
time. But what if...  there is another child somewhere...  also born at 
that time to parents that said no to the dark lord 3x.  What if... that 
child was the HBP?  What if it takes 3 of them all born on July 31st. 
What if...  

Well, we have to talk about something till July. Might as well start 
some far, off the wall idea.  Earlier today I also had a thought that 
the HBP was PP. I am just a bit nutty tonight. Are we going to have a 
lottery or game or something to guess who it is??  ;-)

By the way I was looking at a chocolate frog cards tonight and the one 
for Voldemort has a full moon on it..  what is that all about?? 

Tonks_op