What are your hopes and fears for Severus Snape?
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Tue Apr 26 01:01:20 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 128071
Lupinlore:
What are your hopes for the character of Severus Snape? Where
would you like to see his character going. On the other hand, what
are your fears about where you think his character WILL go?
<SNIP>
Where I fear he IS going is:
1) his inability to control his feelings with regard to Harry will
lead to disaster,
2) I think he will end up being on the good side in the end, but
thecost of his "redemption" will be his death;
3) I doubt we will ever see any real growth in his character;
Alla:
Well, I stated just about ten thousand times that I agree with your
hopes for Snape, so I am not going to say it again, but I did want
to comment on one of your fears.
I am still thinking about Peter and I am more and more inclined to
think that he will die by saving Harry and thus earning redemption.
If such thing happens, I think that doing the same thing with Snape
will be a bit duplicative. I mean it is not a certainty, but a
posibility.
Nuh, I think that Snape just may survive. :-)
As to the first fear of yours, I think it may play out just fine
too, IF it will happen. Maybe , it will finally help Snape to see
Harry for himself. You know, Harry not holding such disaster against
Snape, blah, blah, blah.
Accordingly it may lead to his character growth or it may not, since
he IS secondary character after all.
Just my opinion,
Alla.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive