LV not fulfulling the terms of the prophecy? (long)

Kelsy hpfans at mamakelsy.net
Fri Apr 29 23:54:05 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 128297

Angie:
> I think we must assume he struck Harry first b/c presumably Neville
> would be dead if Voldy had reached him first.  I think DD is
> overreaching or misspeaking in stating that DD "chose" Harry b/c he
> thought Harry was the greater threat to him, etc.  And I'm still 
> not convinced that the "marking" is the failed curse scar nor am I
> certain what it means to be Voldy's "equal."


Did you ever think that the reason that Neville's parents are in the 
hospital is they were the first ones to be attacked. Maybe when James 
and Lily went into hiding they had both Neville and Harry with them. 
Maybe James was holding LV (sorry can't spell it correctly) off so 
that Lily could get the boys hidden. Lily might have gotten Neville 
into the hiding place and was about to get Harry there, but LV got 
into the room first. Effectively stopping Lily from hiding Harry with 
Neville or she would expose both of them to LV. There is the missing 
day that is not accounted for after the attack.

Hagrid could have very well retrieved both boys from the ruins. Taken 
Neville to his Grandmother and then delivered Harry to the Dursleys in 
the same time frame and not really alter the facts that we have of 
that day.

Just my 2 cents

Kelsy 







More information about the HPforGrownups archive