LV not fulfulling the terms of the prophecy? (long)

[quigonginger]

No: HPFGUIDX 128307

Kelsy:
> Did you ever think that the reason that Neville's parents are in the 
> hospital is they were the first ones to be attacked. Maybe when 
James 
> and Lily went into hiding they had both Neville and Harry with them. 
> Maybe James was holding LV (sorry can't spell it correctly) off so 
> that Lily could get the boys hidden. Lily might have gotten Neville 
> into the hiding place and was about to get Harry there, but LV got 
> into the room first. Effectively stopping Lily from hiding Harry 
with 
> Neville or she would expose both of them to LV. There is the missing 
> day that is not accounted for after the attack.
(snip)

Ginger:  
This comes up a lot, but it can't be.  The attack on the Longbottoms 
took place well after LV attacked the Potters.  How long is not 
known.  The only reference we have is DD's comment in GoF ch. 30 (p. 
603 US paperback) that "the attacks on them came after Voldemort's 
fall from power, just when everyone thought they were safe."  We've 
speculated, but come to no conclusions.  It may have been several 
months or a few years.  Steve (bboymn) has had some good posts on 
this.  Maybe he'll jump in?

Ginger, "Support Levitated Objects!"