Sirius' attempted murder of Snape

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 135975

> Lisa responds:  

<SNIP>
In that light, I really can't see how sending Snape into
> (below) the Whomping Willow could be viewed as anything but
attempting
> to dispose of Snape for good.


Alla:

OK, I have to ask that question again - how exactly did Sirius SENT 
Snape to Shack? Did he tied him up? Did he put him under Imperio?

Don't you think that Snape bares at least some share of
responsibility  
for going there in the first place?

Oh, and here is my favorite question of all times why would Snape
stop 
and listen to ANYTHING Snape says?

Don't you think that Snape, smart as he is would view anything Sirius 
says as suspect?

JMO,

Alla