Horcruxes: Groundrules and Theories

[tlpbupu]

No: HPFGUIDX 136182

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Kim McGibony <empooress at g...> 
wrote:
> 
> Is Harry a horcrux, I'd have to say no.  I don't believe he would 
have
> had time to
> perform what must be a very complex bit of magic. And at the end of
> OOtP, Voldy was unable to stand being inside of Harry. And well, I
> just don't think he be trying so hard to kill him if he was a 
horcrux.
> 
> Empooress


tlpbupu:
   I completely agree with this statement and would just like to add 
one question.  When would Voldy have made Harry a horcrux?  Since 
OOTP we know why Voldemort tried to kill Harry as a baby and that is 
what he went there to do.  In Goblet he actually takes a part of 
Harry (blood), but shows no magic that could be interpreted as 
creating a horcrux.  In OOTP again Voldemort and Harry have very 
little actually time physically together with no signs of magic that 
we have not already been shown.  I agree with Empooress that it must 
be a very complex piece of magic to separte your soul from your body 
even if it is "torn".
    To the people who do believe that Harry is a horcrux, please 
tell me when you think that this happened because right now my sleep 
deprived little mind cannpt think of a time this would be possible.

And the usually disclaimers of sorry if this has been brought up, 
but can anyone honestly keep up with all of these posts!

tlpbupu (who after she is told exactly when and where, many times 
I'm sure, will slowely retreat back into lurkdom)