accidental horcrux

[Cathy Drolet]

No: HPFGUIDX 136199

Elaine

>>Ok this is totally off the wall but lets just say the voice we hear 
at godrix hollow you know "take Harry and run" was not James but 
Snape (as has been suggested here before, and would explain JKR 
cutting James from that movie scene) 

CathyD now:

But Harry has heard Snape's voice for 6 years, and he heard the the voice in your quote which he presumed to be James, then he heard James' voice during the Priori Incantatem with Voldemort.  Don't you think he would have noticed if they were the same?  That doesn't preclude Snape being at Goderic's Hollow, just that I don't think it was Severus telling Lily to go.  That scene cut also led to a great pile of speculation that James and Lupin had switched bodies and that Lupin, in POA, was really James.  JKR squashed that quite soundly when she said that James would never have left his wife and son to die while protecting himself.

Somebody - obviously - had to have been with Voldemort at Goderic's Hollow.  Voldemort's body was gone (if it didn't just *poof*) and his wand was gone and ended up back in his possession.  We know he couldn't hold a wand in his VapourMort state, he says so in GOF.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]