Re: Dumbledore’s flawed plan

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 136222

"Donna" <donnawonna at w...> wrote:

> But it won't be pointless, if 
> Dumbledore was going to die from
> the Potion he drank anyway. It 
> is mentioned in the book, that
> there are Potions for which no 
> antidote exists, therefore it 
> should not have been ruled out 
> that Dumbledore *knew* his days
> were numbered. 

But how could Snape have known what the potion was or known that
Dumbledore drank it or even know that there was a potion? Until just a
few minutes before even Dumbledore didn't know there was a potion.

> And in this case the sacrifice makes
> sense, because otherwise Snape would
> have died as well(see the Unbreakable Vow). 

If Snape is good then he would have to be brain dead dumb to make the
Unbreakable Vow, every explanation I've read trying to explain this
away are lame in the extreme.

Eggplant