SHIP: Harry, Ginny
coolbeans3131
joj at rochester.rr.com
Thu Aug 4 00:38:13 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 136320
Lynn wrote:
A big point of the scene wasn't Ginny or even the Kiss, it was how
Ron would
react to the ship.
Joj writes:
So, Jo has been building this romance between the hero and his
perfect equal partner, who's been in love with him for 5 years, and
the point of their first kiss scene is Ron's reaction? And that's ok
with you?
Fran wrote:
I can kinda see the need to have "experience" in order to
fill in the gaps; however, I don't think it's necessary for readers
to have had a teenage romance in order to understand Harry and
Ginny. ... when I read the scene where
Harry comes back from detention and sees Ginny--and just kisses her
because she had that "blazing" look in her eyes/on her face, it
worked for me. Not because as a teenager, I had a romance like
that; nor because I've kissed anyone like that upon seeing a
particular "blazing" look on their face (not that I'd be against it;
I just haven't). Heck, I can't say any of my relationships have
panned out so well that I could relate it to any of the
relationships in the books--maybe I'm gifted and have a vivid
imagination.
Joj:
I married my highschool sweetheart, but I cannot picture or feel or
care about H/G's relationship in any way. I doesn't grate on me like
R/H"s, it's just a big nothing.
And what exactly is this blazing look supposed to look like?
phoenixgod2000 wrote:
I leave with this thought: The title of the current anti-H/G thread
at fictionalley is called 'Even George Lucas is laughing at you'.
Pretty much says it all.
Joj:
Bwahaha!! I'm definitely going to go read that!!
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive