If Harry is NOT a Horcrux...

spotsgal Nanagose at aol.com
Thu Aug 4 07:06:22 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 136374

>Empooress:
>I don't think that Harry's ablity to fight the Imperious curse had
>anything to do with Voldy, his mom and dad were powerful wizards.
>Some of his ablities must come from them.

Christina:

Exactly.  Harry has shown magical talent before (ie, the Patronus
Charm).  Also, didn't Voldemort give Harry some additional magical
power when he tried to AK him?  That's why he can speak Parseltongue
and such.

>Empooress:
>Once again, I will state that there just is no logical way for Harry
>to be a horcrux.

Christina:

I agree with you, 100%.  Even if Harry *was* a horcrux, wouldn't
Voldemort's incorporation of his (Harry's) blood into his present self
reunite that particular piece of his soul with his human
(err..."human"?) self?  I suppose you could say that that's what could
have accounted for DD's gleam (one less horcrux to destroy), although
I would think that it would have only made the current Voldemort more
powerful and difficult to defeat.  Not to mention the fact that
Dumbledore would have mentioned any suspicion of this to Harry (I
would think).


Christina






More information about the HPforGrownups archive