Was Snape ever loved?
Samantha
samwisep at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 5 10:48:23 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 136540
("Maybe she is in hiding as the Hogwarts librarian, Irma Pince (i.e. Im
a Prince :)"
Cheryl
I think this is an excellent theory, with only one complication. When
Harry is in the library with his copy of Advance Potions, Irma Pince
sees it and goes ballistic, thinking he had defaced the book. If,as
some theories suggest, Snape's mother wrote the potion revisions in
the book, she surely would have recognized the book and/or her
handwriting(if she was Snape's mother) now, on the other hand, she
could be Snape's mother and HE(maybe with some Lily help?)wrote the
revisions(in which case she would have been oblivious and still
thought Harry had defaced it)
I think Irma Prince( I'm a prince)Is just the type of play on words
that JKR likes, so it is a really,really good theory!
Snapeo'phile
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive