Harry not a Horcrux

shgupta83 shgupta83 at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 5 18:44:57 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 136634

I don't know if anyone has mentioned this yet, and I apoligize if I'm 
just repeating it, but I don't think voldemort has finished making 
his horcruxes yet. Dumbledore said that when Harry's parents died, 
Voldemort only had 5 horcruxes, not including himself. After he 
failed in his attempt to kill Harry, I believe he was still 1 
horcrux short of his goal. Dumbledore says that after being 
regenerated he made Nagini a horcrux. I find this part of the 
explanation unlikely, because Voldemort has a fixation on killing 
Harry personally. In GOF, Wormtail told voldemort the task of 
regenerating his body could be done much easier without having to 
capture and kill Harry. However Voldemort insisted on using Harry. 
Even in HBP, Voldemort orders his death eaters not to kill Harry. We 
know that he uses special deaths to create the Horcruxes, so I 
really think hes waiting to kill Harry to make his final one. If 
this were true, then it eliminates either Nagini as a horcrux (which 
maybe he intends to use as the object for the horcrux once he kills 
Harry) or one of the other remaining horcruxes (the cup, or the 
object from Gryfindor/Ravenclaw) as being a real horcrux.
It seems unlikey with so many loose ends to tie up in book seven, 
Rowling can actually fit a plot line of Harry searching and 
destroying 4 more Horcruxes. 

shgupta83








More information about the HPforGrownups archive