Spinner's End in Real Life (and a trailor tip)

[vmonte]

No: HPFGUIDX 136717

Cindy wrote:

So if my line of reasoning is correct, why on earth would Snape take
that vow? Even if he is ESE!Snape, taking the vow meant going
against the Dark Lord's wishes. If he is Good!Snape, taking the vow
meant he was going to have to kill Dumbledore (even if DD was
weakened to the point of death, and Snape could envision using that
to "prove" he was loyal to LV by killing DD, it's circular reasoning
because Snape already proved disloyalty by taking the vow)...

vmonte:
How was Snape disloyal to Voldemort again? I'm pretty sure that 
Draco's task was meant as a test for Snape. Voldemort was testing 
Snape. He wanted to see just how far Snape would go to make sure that 
his wishes would come true. Having Draco lose face with the DEs, who 
would see him as a coward, was Voldemort's revenge on Lucius's family.

Vivian