RAB-why not just sign?

Matt hpfanmatt at gmx.net
Sat Aug 6 20:35:57 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 136761

---  Leah <"littleleahstill"> wrote:
> The writer of the note in the locket has three things to 
> communicate: that s/he has the horcrux and means to 
> destroy it; that s/he wants Voldemort to know that it is 
> the writer who has discovered the horcrux secret; that 
> s/he will be dead before Voldemort discovers what has 
> happened.
> 
> That being so, there seems no good reason for the writer 
> not to proudly sign [his or her] name, say 'Regulus Black'.
> If, on the other hand, s/he wants to protect family etc 
> from revenge in due course, why give any clue to identity, 
> such as initials?  
> 
> Is there a reason for the initials, other than Ms Rowling 
> having a bit of fun with us?  Are these initials which 
> Voldemort will immediately recognise ... ?  

I'd say yes; at least that was my line of thinking when I read the
note.  I took it as another clue (in addition to the use of the
moniker "Dark Lord") that the writer was a Death Eater: Often people
who work together address and sign communications with their initials,
and this person clearly expected Voldemort to recognize his (or hers).  

-- Matt










More information about the HPforGrownups archive