Snape Lying to Bellatrix (was: Spinner's End Most Important Clues Chapter?)

[profuloth]

No: HPFGUIDX 136819

> Christina wrote:
> The Foe-Glass shows one's enemies.  If Snape had intended all along to
> rejoin the Death Eaters, he would have technically been on
> Fake!Moody's side and shouldn't have shown up in the mirror.  The fact
> that he does appear shows that his allegiance was not with LV at that
> point, making his remark to Bella a lie.

The question here is this: Does a foe glass show you your true enemies or your perceived 
enemies? Remember when Fake!Moody says their is nothing he hates more than a DE that 
walked free, those lines were true for both Real!Moody and Fake!Moody. As a result, Fake!
Moody (Crouch Jr if you prefer) would perceive Snape as an enemy despite Snape's alliance 
with Voldy.

Jason