What Dark Arts?

quick_silver71 quick_silver71 at yahoo.ca
Mon Aug 8 00:29:07 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 136894

Colebiancardi wrote:

> but why didn't he turn Harry over to DD to be expelled?  Snape never
> had a problem before with that.  And I don't buy the "Snape didn't
> want Dumbledore to know about the book" excuse that Hermione came up
> with.  DD knew that Snape was a DE and into Dark Arts - why would 
this
> suprise him for something that Snape did when he was a teen?  I still
> think Snape & DD knew(not Sluggie).  JMHO
> 

Quick Silver:
Probably because if Harry was expelled then Draco would have be too. 
Snape and Dumbledore spent a year trying to save Draco and if he got 
expelled for starting a duel and attempting to use an Unforgivable 
Curse they wouldn't be there for him, would they? Besides there is 
probably a lot of procedure to expell a student...which could uncover 
a lot about Snape (since it is his book) and Draco (who is actually at 
fault for the duel).









More information about the HPforGrownups archive