Foe glass

[smilingator4915]

No: HPFGUIDX 136915

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "April Johnson" <April at c...> wrote:
>    "spotsgal" wrote:
>   > The workings of the Foe-Glass are never explained in detail, so 
>   > it's possible it only shows what you believe to be your enemies, 
>   > although it seems that it would be much more useful if the mirror 
>   > could detect that itself (the same way that a Sneakoscope is 
>   > valuable because it detects the untrustworthy people
>   > for you).
> 
>   (snip)
> 
> 
>   April:
> 
>   I was thinking about this.  Is it possible that what Harry himself
sees in the foe glass are HIS enemies and not FakeMoody's.   In the
mirror of erised, the person sees in the mirror their own desires, not
someone elses.  So it would make sense that Harry would see Snape in
the mirror.

smilingator:

Well, Harry also saw DD and Prof. McGonagall in the foe glass, so
wouldn't that make them his enemies too if the foe glass? Well, unless
he was seeing both his enemies AND Fake Moody's enemies. OR... no...
JKR wouldn't do that to us... but another option is that DD and
McGonagall are Harry's enemies too (but I HIGHLY HIGHLY doubt this).

Just my thoughts...