Snape's writing
potioncat
willsonkmom at msn.com
Mon Aug 8 11:36:12 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 136923
Duffypoo wrote:
> > But the question is, why doesn't Harry recognize the writing in
> the book as Snape's when he's seen Snape's handwriting at the time
> when Snape would have been writing in this book?
Potioncat:
Well, I recognised the writing at once, but was thrown off by the Half-
blood part, by the book being so old and by Lupin's not recognising the
name.
There have been many times (several times at least) when Harry hasn't
recognised something or someone and besides, he liked the advice he was
getting.
Lupin's not recognising the name reminds me of Lupin and Snape
pretending not to recognise the names on the Marauders' Map. I wonder
if he's telling the truth in this case?
Snape has lied before (gasp!) so maybe he's lying here.
However, I think it is supposed to be Snape's handwriting and he is
supposed to be the one who made up the spells and he is the Half-Blood
Prince.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive