SHIP: Ginny Unknowingly Wearing Love Potion

uilnslcoap devin.smither at yale.edu
Tue Aug 9 16:16:18 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 137052

I haven't posted her in years, but I can't stand for this.

Utterly preposterous.  This theory has no merit whatever.  Why wasn't 
Harry going nuts for Ginny the way Ron was for Romilda?  If it were 
love potion that caused his attraction, he'd give no consideration to 
the idea that Ginny is Ron's sister and therefore out of bounds; he'd 
just go for her.  Why does Ginny stay with Dean all that time if 
she's using uncanonical "love potion perfume" on Harry?  It's clear 
that love potions smack of scents that one (consciously or 
subconsciously) associates with romance.  Harry didn't smell the love 
potion Ginny was wearing in Potions; Harry smelled Ginny.  There's no 
room for assuming there can be a love potion perfume when there's no 
evidence for it AT ALL in canon.  Harry likes Ginny.  Both Ron and 
Hermione like that Harry likes Ginny.  Big frickin' deal.

> for why I think she's wearing love potion as perfume.  And as for 
> knowingly or unknowingly, see that same thread, message #136849 
> about how Hermione could have unknowingly passed a bottle of the 
> twins' love potion disguised as perfume to Ginny, Del`s idea 
> actually.  And then there is the thread, "SHIP: Pirate Ginny" 
> starting with message #133015, in which I think she is doing it 
> intentionally. 
> 
> 
> The book doesn't actually say there is such a thing as love potion 
> perfume.  However, Jo showed us in Potions class that love potion 
> fumes have a subtle, and less obvious effect than from ingesting 
> it.  And Hermione tells us that she read on the back of a bottle in 
> the twins' shop that their love potions can be owl ordered 
disguised 
> as perfume or cough potion. So Ginny could have purchased some 
> through Verity the clerk, or Ron might have unknowingly given some 
> to Hermione for Christmas.  And she didn't care for it, so could 
> have passed it to Ginny - maybe when she gave Ginny advice to move 
> on from Harry.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive