Neville's new wand/ unicorn hair/Ravenclaws wand

clarinut76 clarinut76 at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 11 04:49:51 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 137275

Ehren:

<snip>
> The only problem with this being the final horcux is that 
> Voldemort wouldn't let something so valuble be sitting in a wand 
> shop where people are constantly walking by it day in and day out 
> and Ollivander wouldn't be able to just let Neville have it (even 
> if the wand did choose him) unless it was Voldies plan to do so. 


Rachel again: This is a good question.  Why would LV put the wand in 
a very obvious place?  We could ask who had this wand once it was 
turned into a horcrux?  Could the DE who was in charge of it try to 
get rid of it (a la Mr. Malfoy in CoS?) for personal gain?  Maybe Mr. 
Ollivander, having made the wand, tried to reaquire it after 
Ravenclaw died?  Who could have owned the wand in between Ravenclaw 
and getting it back to the shop?  That's redundant...sorry.  Just 
rephrasing, I guess.

Ehren:
> (by the way, Rachel I was looking at your email, do play the 
clarinet? 
> If so rock on! Us muscian/HP fans must bond together thru the 
internet)
> I'm ironing my hands now for going briefly off-topic. It won't 
happen again.

Rachel:
I'll give a brief answer to this as well...My husband is the 
clarinetist (you guessed it...it was clarinet & nut put together...he 
truly is one!)  I'm a cellist myself.  I'll bang my head against a 
chest of drawers as punishment.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive