SHIP: Ginny Unknowingly Wearing Love Potion (a great Essay on the subject)
NamiePark
namiepark at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 11 23:50:06 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 137339
Phoenixgod wrote:
>
> > Just today I found a great essay on the subject of Harry/Ginny
and
> > Love Potions that I found deeply compelling. While I didn't like
H/G
> > in the book I never subscribed to the love potion theory because
it
> > strikes me as too conspiracyish but the author of the article
lays
> > out a very compelling argument that Hermione has dowsed harry
with
> > love potions in an effort to nudge Harry in Ginny's direction.
Hi, this is my first post here so if I make a mistake, please don't
be too hard on me. I don't know if anyone has pointed this out
before (I've read most but not all of the HBP messages) or not but I
don't think a love potion was involved re: Harry/Ginny. We are able
to see firsthand how love potion affects someone--when Ron
accidentally eats a potion-infused chocolate intended for Harry. He
instantly seems to almost go crazy--he can't stop talking about the
girl (sorry, can't remember her name)--he's so overtaken with her
that he must hunt her down and his mind is singlemindedly and
completely devoted to her. Harry's attraction to Ginny, while it
did come as a shock to him, seems to have developed more slowly--and
certainly did not render him incapable of continuing on with normal
activities in his life the way it did with Ron.
I suppose Harry could have been affected with a milder potion but
I'm inclined to think that JKR purposely showed us the
effect of love potion on Ron so that we can identify the symptoms
readily and not confuse it with just a growing attraction/romance.
IMHO
"NamiePark"
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive