Snape and Voldemort WAS:Dumbledore and Snape again
Julia
jolka55 at poczta.onet.pl
Fri Aug 12 08:40:28 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 137366
Julia wrote:
> > IMO neither Nercissa nor her sister told Voldemort about
> > the Vow so imagine his surprise when he finds out that out
> > of blue Snape (who wasn't informed about the Mission or
> > when Draco will attempt to fulfill it) turns out at the
> > crime scene AKs Dumbledore grabs Draco and runs away...
> <snip>
> > I wonder if Snape wouldn't have a hard time explaining how
> > did he knew about the Mission (I'm absolutely sure that he
> > lied to Narcissa and he didn't know about Draco mission to
> > kill DD) ....
> Matt responded:
> Not sure what Voldemort will think, though we know Draco thinks
Snape
> will succeed in "stealing his glory" by taking over his mission.
>
> Just wanted to respond to the point quoted above: While Snape may
or
> may not have known what the mission was at Spinner's End, the Death
> Eaters on the tower seem to assume that he knows about it by that
> point. So presumably either Snape himself has reported back about
it,
> or someone else has reported back about Snape trying to "help out"
> Malfoy. It's unlikely, therefore, that Voldemort will be
surprised to
> hear that Snape was aware of the mission.
Julia again:
Yes, Draco thinks that Snape wants glory - but we know it's not
true, Snape not only doesn't want glory but he doesn't want anybody
to find out he is helping... The Vow is some kind of a treachery to
Voldemort and was taken behind his back so I don't think Snape would
be eager to tell his fellow DEs about it! (They'll probably go
straight to Voldemort cause nobody likes SS anyway - they 'whisper
behind his back' as he himslef told Bellatrix)
I don't think that he reported back to Voldemort about the Vow for
the same reasons I stated above. This was a treachery and Voldemort
wouldn't like it. And if Snape told him this he would make
Narcissa's situation even worse...
When Snape turnes out on the tower one of the DE says 'We've got a
problem Sanpe; the boy doesn't seem able...' IMO the present DEs
didn't know if Snape knew about the Mission. They probably assumed
it when he stood in the door. maybe they thought that Voldemort just
didn't tell them that but as Snape works in Hogwarts they assumed he
must have been filled in. There wasn't time for them to ask Snape -
Dumbledore can regain his powers at any moment, OotP can come in any
second too. IMO they just thought he knew. Voldemort didn't share
his thoughts and whole plans with DE so they're used to work
together without knowing about each others orders...
Julia
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive