Sleeping Portrait was Faked death or faked AK?

Constance Vigilance ConstanceVigilance at gmail.com
Fri Aug 12 14:26:13 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 137391

 CV: I think Dumbledore is alive. I think the Draft of Living Death 
> 
> Ronaldo:
> I thought al the phoenix imagery was a clue to a possible
> "rebirth", like phoenixes die and then are reborn.

CV: I don't think it was an image. I think it was Dumbledore's
patronus  sending a message to the Order that everything is fine, go
along with the plan. 

> I feel the speech DD gave to the Dursleys in the beginning
> of the book was a clue to the fact that he didn't expect
> to be around one year later...
> 
> Ronaldo

CV: I think it was really a message meant for Harry. "Don't skip this
last bit of protection while I'm away." As soon as Harry stops calling
the Dursleys' "home", the protection goes away. That would be after
Dumbldore's "death" unless Dumbledore makes sure otherwise. There is
really no point to making such a speech for the Dursleys' benefit. As
long as Petunia thinks Dumbledore is viable, then she will make sure
that Harry has a home there. I wish I knew what leverage Dumbledore
has over Petunia.

Constance Vigilance 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive