It's over, Snape is evil

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 137609

Kathryn Jones <kjones at t...> wrote:


> So, you would have Snape kill Amycus,
> while the rest stand by with their
> mouths hanging open, then Greyback,
> then Alecto, who is also still frozen
> in shock, then the last DE, and then Draco 

Yes, that is exactly what I would have Snape do. After Dumbledore's
death Harry chased the Death Eaters and defeated several of them one
on one, I have no doubt when he was healthy Dumbledore could have
taken on all of them at once and I think Snape could too. You will
note that when Snape entered the room all the other Death Eaters
seemed terrified with him, and although Harry had little difficulty
dealing with the other Death Eaters he had much more trouble with
Snape. I think only Dumbledore and Voldemort were more powerful than
Snape, so when he found one of those wizards without a wand and in a
weakened state he did not hesitate for one split second to kill him.

> I'm sure that JKR will find a way for
> Snape to contact someone a little 
> more receptive than you. If not, I
> can see some serious plot holes
> looming in book 7. 

I never liked Snape and was always a bit mystified why so many felt
that deep down he's really just a sweetheart, but before HBP JKR could
perhaps morphed him into a good guy, or at least into a less
despicable character; but now JKR has burned her bridges as far as
Snape is concerned. After what we saw in HBP if she tries to turn
Snape into a good guy the last book in the Potter series will be a
disaster because killing Dumbledore is quite simply unforgivable.  

Eggplant