Snape deserves to die, but...

eggplant107 eggplant107 at hotmail.com
Mon Aug 15 20:21:36 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 137725

"tbernhard2000" <lunalovegood at s...> wrote:

>  Snape deserves to die

Agreed.

> but neither Harry nor I are bent on revenge. 

Speak for yourself. Harry is not Dumbledore who seems incapable of
hate or even to fully understand what the word means, but Harry
understands because he is more human. As Dumbledore says Harry can
love but he can also hate and there is nobody on the planet he hates
more than Severus Snape, and that includes Voldemort. 

> Harry, being beyond mere revenge, isn't 
> all that interested in getting the
> murderer Snape

I think you're wrong, I think Harry has more than a passing interest
in murdering Snape, I certainly hope so. At least once before this
series is over I want to see Harry Potter turn into Dirty Harry, I
want to see him become positively scary. I really hope JKR doesn't
take this winning ultimate victories with nothing but love business
too far. When Harry and Snape meet again as I'm sure they will I don't
want to hear wimpy stuff about forgive and forget, and I don't want
Harry to kill Snape with love, I want a bloodbath, I want gunfight at
the OK Corral, I want Night of The Living Dead grade rage on Harry's
part. And I have my hopes because Harry is not a saint like
Dumbledore, thank goodness.  

 Eggplant









More information about the HPforGrownups archive