[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape deserves to die, but...

[d.]

No: HPFGUIDX 137737

--- colebiancardi <muellem at bc.edu> wrote:
> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "eggplant107" <eggplant107 at h...> 
>  > I think you're wrong, I think Harry has more than a passing interest
> > in murdering Snape, I certainly hope so. At least once before this
> > series is over I want to see Harry Potter turn into Dirty Harry, I
> > want to see him become positively scary. I really hope JKR doesn't
> > take this winning ultimate victories with nothing but love business
> > too far. When Harry and Snape meet again as I'm sure they will I 
> > want to hear wimpy stuff about forgive and forget, and I don't want
> > Harry to kill Snape with love, I want a bloodbath, I want gunfight at
> > the OK Corral, I want Night of The Living Dead grade rage on Harry's
> > part. And I have my hopes because Harry is not a saint like
> > Dumbledore, thank goodness.  
> 
> I think you are reading the wrong books if that is what you expect. I 
> doubt JKR will do that, as these are supposed to be children's books.  
> There hasn't been a bloodbath yet, and I doubt there will be.  Let's 
> not forget, Voldemort is the EVIL guy, the true villian.  Snape, well, 
> is just Snape and no one, except Rowling, knows what side he will be 
> on.

See what I mean by Snape stealing LV's thunder?  XD LV did nothing for anyone, it is
Snape, always Snape that touch the heart of readers. And the deeply disturbed and angry
rabid Snape haters here demands blood and death, a la Death Wish. I wonder what would
happen if for some miraclous reason this fictional character didn't end up dead nor bad
ending at the end, what are you poor wounded souls gonna do? The rage~~~ oh my~~

Eggplant is definitely reading the wrong book to  me. JKR is no Mel Gibson, if Harry were
to murder Snape in some primal rage, then Harry and his so-called "goodness" (and his
supposedly GREAT super power of LUV) is complete bullsh*t, or as Ginny would say, Harry
is the biggest, disgusting, vile and filthy hypocrite!  There's no way
Harry-the-boy-who-has-the-remarkable-love-powered hero is "heroic" and "good" if he's a
murderous killer. He'd be just like the "murderer Snape" that he accused Snape of, what's
the difference? How DARE Harry-the-murderer to consider himself different and 'good',
puhleaze...it's pathetic. Even Draco didn't had it in him to kill. Yet Eggplant expects
Harry to?  Eggplant, face it, Harry is LOVE and GOOD! You can get your dirty Harry in
fanfic. But in the book,  Harry, has remarkable capacity of love and empathy (whatever
that means), he let Peter Pettigrew go, it is LOVE that JKR set Harry up for, it is LOVE
who sets Harry apart from as superior.  Love love love love love...that is Harry...makes
you sick? If so then you're going to be greatly disappointed when book 7 comes.

Snape deserves to die as much as (as if death is the worst thing ever could happen to a
fictional character *roll eye*)...Harry/Ginny deserves to be written more convincing and
likable way if they're like oh so important. it's all...just readers' raging wishful
demands. 

D.