Slughorn "clearly good"?

[H.M.S]

No: HPFGUIDX 137888

Heathrawlings:
<SNIP>
"I see him as resigning himself to his fate on behalf of good and 
agreeing to go to Hogwarts, not to play a huge part necessarily, but 
because seeing the ring (and Harry) remind him of the role his has 
however unwittingly played in LV's rise and he knows it's the least 
he can do to accept DD's request to return to Hogwarts.



Uh Uh - Slughorn returned to Hogwarts because he believed he would be in the most protected place, where DE's couldn't force him to join up.  Also, Hogwarts provided opportunity to have fresh young minds looking up to him, after a year in hiding even from his "fans".  IE Slughorn was looking after #1 - his own precious fat & pampered butt!!

Sharon
(Durban, South Africa)