Do the math
potioncat
willsonkmom at msn.com
Wed Aug 17 17:03:20 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 137900
Fabian:
> Didn't he go to Voldemort first though and tell him about the
prophecy?
> What I don't get it is why he did this, if he's supposed to be on the
> 'good side'. I mean that would mean:
> 1. Snape told Voldemort about the prophecy
> 2. Snape tries to figure out who the child is
> 3. Once he has found this out, he tells Dumbledore
> 4. Dumbledore asks why on earth Snape told Voldemort in the first
place!
Potioncat:
DD said in HBP that the eavesdropper was in LV's employ. It crossed my
mind that he could also already be in DD's as well...or not.
But the first half of the prophecy does not make it clear that the one
will be born soon. It says born to those who thrice defied, and as the
7th month dies. But it wasn't clear that it wasn't a child or adult
already born. The last half of the prophecy says "will be born". So
LV may have been looking at adult or young adult wizards who had been
born in July.
So, in August or so, Snape is reading the Daily Prophet between Muggle
baiting and Poisen-potion brewing and sees the birth announcements for
July. He says to himself, "Blimey! It's Lovely Lily's child that will
do in the Boss."
LV in the mean time tells Snape to go get a job with DD so that he can
bring in more info. So Snape, now having a cover, goes to DD and tells
all.
Or not.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive