It's over, Snape is evil

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 138002

"Cathy Drolet" <cldrolet at s...> wrote:

> The only *proof* that Snape killed 
> Dumbledore is the eye-witness 
> account of three Death Eaters, one
> wanna-be Death Eater, one Werewolf
> and Harry Potter 

Not true, one other person saw Snape kill Dumbledore, the Narrator;
and in 6 books the Narrator has never EVER been wrong. The Narrator
never saw Sirius Black kill anyone, he just saw people say they saw
him do it. And the Narrator never said he saw Barty Crouch Jr die in
Azkaban, he just heard people claim they had seen it. But things are
quite different in the Snape Dumbledore murder, the Narrator saw it,
he saw all of it and saw it first hand, he was not shy about telling
we readers all about it either. 

> I'd say the evidence that LV 
> killed James and Lily is just
> a little stronger as the Murderer
> himself has said he did it

The Narrator never saw James and Lilly's murder, the closest is Harry
foggy memory of it, we don't have all the gory details like in
Dumbledore's murder. And as for Voldemort's confession, well, we know
a House Elf and Voldemort's uncle also confessed to murders but in
reality they killed nobody.

Please understand, I am not saying for one instant that Voldemort did
not kill James and Lilly, the evidence is very strong enormously
strong, that he did, but the evidence is even stronger that Snape
murdered Dumbledore.

Eggplant