It's over, Snape is evil

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 138085

"Cathy Drolet" <cldrolet at s...> wrote:

> who exactly do you think the Narrator is? 

The Narrator is the fellow who says "Then Harry went over there and
thought this and that". Actually I've heard a rumor that the Narrator
is really a woman but uses a penname. 

> The Narrator let us believe that 
> Scabbers was just a rat 

Not true, the Narrator said Scabbers was a rat and that was perfectly
true, the Narrator never said that's all he was.

> We were led to believe that Buckbeak
> had been executed when he had not. 

Not true, the Narrator never saw Buckbeak executed, the Narrator heard
a chopping sound and a cry of some sort, the Narrator did not say if
it was due to grief or joy.

> his Avada Kadavra of Snape's, which
> is so, to me, blantantly obviously 
> different than the others the 
> Narrator also showed

Not true, the curse that killed Lilly and James not only left a scar
it destroyed a house.

> I could continue in this vein for pages

Me too.

Eggplant