Amelia Bones = RAB?

[carodave92]

No: HPFGUIDX 138093

Auria <rytal at y...> wrote:
<snip>
> R.A.B - could this be Amelia Bones? 

Carodave replies:
During Harry's hearing in OotP, her name is noted in Percy's 
log as Amelia Susan Bones.

Auria <rytal at y...> wrote:
> <snip>  could this mean Amelia Bones was a secret Death 
> Eater?  There is some sense to this in that the DEs have 
> spies in the Ministry of Magic so its very possible.  She 
> could also have been the one to have put Herbert Chorley
> under the Imperius curse.

Carodave replies:
After the DEs escape Azkaban in OotP, Susan Bones gets additional 
attention at school, as a member of the Bones family, who suffered 
severe losses during Voldemort's rise to power. (I think Moody 
mentions this as well when he shows Harry the photo of original 
Order members). I can't believe that Jo would make a member of the 
Bones family a DE when the family is so hard hit by the DEs. I 
realize that Sirius is killed by his cousin Bellatrix, but that is 
more of a one-on-one situation, not a whole family being destroyed.  
Also, Arthur Weasley respects Amelia Bones and I don't remember 
him ever having been wrong (except re Percy - and I still have 
faith that he'll come around).
 
Carodave